Important note

This AI stock analysis for CarMax is not up to date. Creating and accessing our AI stock Analysis (powered by our data and Chat GPT) is only available for our premium users. Sign up to get access today!

CarMax - AI Stock Analysis

Analysis generated September 25, 2024

CarMax, Inc. is the largest used-car retailer in the United States, operating a unique business model for buying and selling used vehicles. CarMax offers a broad selection of used vehicles, a highly transparent buying experience, and robust customer service, distinguishing itself in an industry often criticized for opaque practices. Founded in 1993, CarMax has grown significantly over the years and now operates more than 200 retail locations nationwide.

Fundamental Analysis

The last quarter’s revenue for CarMax was $7.11 billion. This represents a growth of 26.42% compared to the preceding quarter but shows a decline of 7.46% compared to the same quarter last year. This mixed signal implies that while the company is recovering on a quarterly basis, it still faces challenges year-over-year.

Net income for the last quarter stood at $152 million, showing a substantial increase of 203.25% compared to the quarter before. However, it reflects a decrease of 33.23% from the same quarter last year. EBITDA for the last quarter was $300 million, an 89.65% increase from the previous quarter but a 24.30% decrease year-over-year. These numbers suggest short-term improvement but long-term instability.

The current Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio of 29.98 is considered high, potentially indicating overvaluation. High P/E ratios can deter value-focused investors, suggesting that the stock might be overvalued given the current earnings. Furthermore, recent insider sell-offs could be a bearish signal, showing lack of confidence from those closest to the company.

Technical Analysis

CarMax's current stock price is $74.49, a 13.16% decrease from a month ago and a 4.81% decrease from a year ago. This indicates a bearish trend in the stock price, which makes short-term and long-term outlooks somewhat concerning. The SMA10 (Simple Moving Average over 10 days) stands at 76.88, which is lower than the previous SMA10 of 77.31, further confirming the downward movement in price.

The Relative Strength Index (RSI) is at 31.7, which stands in the neutral condition band. An RSI close to or below 30 could indicate that the stock is potentially oversold, but as it is still neutral, no strong buy or sell signal arises from here.

Alternative Data Analysis

CarMax appears stable regarding its job market with 1,099 open positions, a figure that has remained consistent over recent months. Employee sentiment about the business outlook is neutral, suggesting stability but no strong growth optimism.

Customer engagement metrics indicate stagnancy: 20 million webpage visitors with no significant fluctuations, 1,900 daily mobile app downloads, and steady follower counts on Instagram and Twitter. The lack of growth in these areas could suggest a plateau in customer acquisition and engagement.

Of note is CarMax's AltIndex AI score of 43, which suggests a "hold" signal. This AI score combines fundamental, technical, and alternative data, making it a significant holistic marker of stock performance.

Conclusion and Recommendation

Overall, CarMax's stock presents a somewhat mixed but cautious scenario. While some short-term fundamentals show positive growth, there remain concerning year-over-year declines. Technically, the stock shows bearish trends, and alternative data indicates stagnancy in both employee sentiment and customer engagement.

Given the current P/E ratio of 29.98 and recent insider sell-offs, the stock may appear overvalued. The current stock price and declining trends (both short and long-term) are further causes for cautiousness. Additionally, the neutral sentiment from AltIndex’s AI score suggests a holding pattern.

Given this comprehensive analysis, a "hold" recommendation seems prudent for existing investors, while potential new investors might consider waiting for a more favorable valuation or strong positive shifts in the company's performance metrics.

Disclaimer: This AI stock analysis, generated by an experimental AI tool, is for informational purposes only and not financial advice. Information is based on publicly available data and may not always be accurate or current.